10 Fish You Should Steer Clear of Ordering at a Restaurant (And What to Choose Instead)


 

Engaging Introduction

That fish on the menu might look fresh and sustainable—but appearances can be deceiving. Some popular seafood choices come with hidden costs: health risks, environmental damage, or ethical concerns that make them poor picks for conscious diners.

I still remember the first time I learned about seafood mislabeling. I was at a nice restaurant, proudly ordering "wild-caught red snapper." Months later, I read a study revealing that nearly 90% of red snapper samples in some regions were actually other, cheaper fish. I felt cheated—not just of money, but of trust.

That experience sent me down a rabbit hole of research. I discovered that some fish are overfished to near extinction. Others accumulate dangerous levels of mercury. Still others come from farming practices that damage ecosystems or mislabeling schemes that cheat consumers.

This guide isn't about fear—it's about empowerment. I'll walk you through 10 fish to avoid, why they're problematic, and what delicious, sustainable alternatives to order instead.


What Makes a Fish "Bad" to Order? (The Three Considerations)

Before we dive into specific fish, let me explain the factors that land a fish on the "avoid" list.

1. Environmental Impact